Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Wednesday:

Please email assigments to nobishomework@gmail.com, as the syllabus states.

"What's Culture Got to Do with it? Excising the Harmful Tradition of Female Circumcision"

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Monday & Tuesday notes


1.      Understand (the theory, the argument, whatever.): what is it?
2.      Arguments in favor of X?
a.      Evaluate the arguments
3.      Arguments against X?
a.      Evaluate the arguments
4.      Given our understanding of X and the arguments for and against X, what should we think about X?

­­­­­

1.      Topic?
2.      Conclusions?
a.      Doing X is MP; doing X is wrong (not MP); doing X is MO
                                                              i.      Precision: sometimes MP, Wrong, or Obligatory? When? Always MP, Wrong or Obligatory?
3.      Premises? (Reasons?)
4.      Logically valid form? (Valid?)
a.      Adding unstated premise(s)
5.      Sound?
a.      Are all the premises true?
                                                              i.      Factual premises / empirical premises / scientific premises
                                                            ii.      Moral principles.. (If an action is like this… then its MP..
1.      Counterexamples?
                                                          iii.      FACTS + MORAL PRINCIPLES = WHAT TO DO

Baby Teresa
Jodie and Mary
Tracy Latimer

“Feel”
“opinion”
To Harm someone = to make them worse off than they were.
If parents want X to happen, then it always MP for X to happen. F
If parents want X to happen and It’s MP for X to happen, then it’s MP for X to happen. F


Monday, June 11, 2012

EMP Ch. 1 Notes

Discussion of Rachels Elements of Moral Philosophy Ch. 1
What is it to ‘Think Morally’?
“Morality is …”

Someone is “thinking morally” or engaged in “moral thinking” when:
(1) one is guiding one’s thought by reasons – the best reasons – and
(2) one gives equal weight to each individual who is affected by one’s actions.

Re. (1): reasons include (scientific, empirical) facts and moral principles.

Facts + Moral Principles = What to Do

Case 1: Baby Theresa L
· What’s her situation?
· What did her parents want to do? What were their reasons?

The parents' argument:
(3) If we can (a) benefit someone without (b) harming anyone else by doing action X, then action X is morally permissible.
(4) By taking Theresa’s organs we can (a) benefit others and (b) not harm anyone else.
(5) So, taking Teresa’s organs is morally permissible.

Is this arguments sound or not?

· What did “the critics” say” (p. 2)

(6) “It’s too horrifying to use people as means to other people’s ends.”
(7) “It’s unethical to kill in order to save, unethical to kill person A to save person B.”
(8) “The parents are saying we should kill the baby to use the organs. That’s horrendous!

These remarks are the basis of arguments. Are these arguments sound or not? If any of them are, then argument (3)-(5) is not sound.

Re. Remark (6):
(A) If someone is used as a means to another’s end, then that is wrong.
(B) Taking Teresa’s organs would be to use her as a means.
(C) So, it would be wrong to take her organs.

Is the argument valid? Are the premises true? (Are they somehow ambiguous or imprecise?)

Re. Remark (7):
(D) If person A is killed to save person B, then that’s wrong.
(E) To kill Teresa would be to kill her to save others.
(F) Therefore, it’s wrong to kill Teresa.

Is the argument valid? Are the premises true? (Are they somehow ambiguous or imprecise?)

Re. Remark (8): ?

Case 2: Jodie and Mary

· What’s their situation? What did her parents want to do? What did the hospital want to do? What were their reasons?
“Whose to decide?!” Asking this kind of question is often a way to avoid thinking about which arguments are best. (Also, it’s often unwise to ask rhetorical questions, since there might be good answer to them).

An argument:
(G) If we have a choice between saving one infant and letting both die, we should save one.
(H) We have such a choice.
(I) So we should save one.

Is the argument valid? Are the premises true?

Some critics say:

(J) If someone is an ‘innocent human life’, then they should never be killed.
(K) Mary is an innocent human life.
(L) Therefore, Mary should not be killed.

Is the argument valid? Are the premises true?

3rd Case: Tracy Latimer
· What’s her situation? (We need to think about the details..)
· What did her parents want to do? What were their reasons?

· What did their critics say?

Take note of:
· Feelings
· Require reasons
· Getting one’s (non-moral) facts straight: checking up on the empirical / scientific evidence
· Impartiality: differences in treatment are justified only by relevant differences in the person/being and in light of general moral principles; otherwise these are unjustified prejudices.

Friday, June 08, 2012

Review for week 1

Here are some questions you should be able to answer, given week 1. Being able to answer these questions will help you prepare for the first quiz.

- - what will we do in this course, according to the extended description?
- what are the course objectives? 

- what is an argument?
- what is it for an argument to be valid or logically valid? (What are at least 2 different ways to explain this concept?)
- can a valid argument have a false premise, or false premises? if so, give an example; if not, explain why not.
- what are the argument patterns modus ponens, modus tollens and universal generalization (or syllogism)?
- what is it for an argument to be sound?

- we will often ask, "Why think that?" and "What do you mean?" Why will we ask and answer these questions?

- although we will use the word 'wrong,' we do not use the word 'right' -- since it is ambiguous (what does that mean?) - but rather use 'morally permissible' and 'morally obligatory'. what do those terms mean? give examples to explain their meaning?

- what is a moral theory? what does a moral theory do or what question(s) does it attempt to answer?
- how did we try to develop a moral theory? what process did we use?
- give a list of actions that most people would think are morally wrong; what are some explanations for why these actions are wrong?

- what is utilitarianism?
- what is Kant's ethics?
- what is the social contract theory of ethics?

Tuesday, June 05, 2012


The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience,
but where he stands at times of challenge and controversy. 
- Martin Luther King Jr. ,‘48

SYLLABUS
AVAILABLE WITH LINKS HERE:

Associated Term: Summer 2012
3.000 Credits
View Catalog Entry 
Scheduled Meeting Times 12:00 pm - 1:20 pm MTWRF Sale Hall 110 Jun 05, 2012 - Jul 13, 2012

Instructor: Nathan Nobis, Ph.D., www.NathanNobis.com
Preferred Email: Nathan.nobis@gmail.com   (preferred email); nnobis@morehouse.edu  
Please send work to this email and/or turn in in class in hardcopy: nobishomework@gmail.com
Telephone: 404-215-2607
Office: Sale Hall 113, Philosophy & Religion Department

Department of Philosophy and Religion: Mission and Objectives:
The two-fold objective of this Department is to prepare students for graduate or professional study in the fields of philosophy and religious studies and to enable them to satisfy the College requirements in the general education program. The courses in philosophy and religion seek to provide the student not only with a firm base in these two academic disciplines, but also with a means for self-examination and self-orientation. The work in philosophy aims to develop a critical and analytical approach to all the major areas of human inquiry. The work in religion aims to describe, analyze and evaluate the role of religion in the life of humans since earliest times and how the religious quest continues as a variegated and often tortuous climb toward human growth and fulfillment.

1.      CATALOG COURSE DESCRIPTION: Provides an introduction to philosophical reflection about the nature and function of morality. Readings will include both historical and contemporary materials.

EXTENDED COURSE DESCRIPTION: This course provides students with the opportunity to improve their skills at reasoning critically about moral issues. Students will learn some basic logical concepts and argument analysis skills and apply them to theoretical and practical questions about morality. We will practice identifying clear (i.e., unambiguous) and precise moral conclusions (i.e., exact perspectives taken on moral issues) and the premises, or reasons, given for and against these conclusions. We will then practice evaluating these reasons to see if they provide rational support for these conclusions or not.
We will think about what helps people think more carefully and critically about moral issues and what factors and influences discourage this.     
We will discuss influential ethical theories and moral principles – answers to the questions ‘What’s the basic difference between a morally permissible and a morally impermissible (or wrong) action?’ and ‘What makeswrong actions wrong and what makes permissible actions permissible?’ – and apply our argument analysis skills to moral issues such as the treatment of disabled newborns, female genital mutilation, homosexuality, abortion, absolute poverty, racism, sexism, and speciesism, vegetarianism and the treatment of animals, euthanasia and assisted suicide, drug use, and capital punishment, among others.

2.      COURSE PREREQUISITES: There are no formal prerequisites for this course. However, students will benefit most from the course when they enter it with the abilities to:
a.       read critically and identify the structure and components of an argumentative essay or passage, i.e., the conclusion(s), the premises(s) or supporting elements, and so forth;
b.      write clear, concise and simple grammatical, spelling-error-free sentences and well-organized expository and argumentative essays, as taught in Introductory English courses;
c.       speak clearly, concisely, and grammatically.
·         Basic mathematical and scientific literacy is desirable.
·         Familiarity with moral issues, common positions taken on them and reasons given in favor of these positions is desirable, since we will build on any previous understanding.
·         Intellectual and moral virtues, such as curiosity, patience, and openness to the possibility of error and the need for change, are desirable as well.

3.      COURSE OBJECTIVES: Upon successfully completing this course, students will be able to use the set ofargument analysis skills below to identify and evaluate moral arguments:
a.       identify whether any presentation (“text”) is “morally argumentative” or not, i.e., whether it presents an argument for a moral conclusion on a moral issue or not;
b.      identify conclusions of morally argumentative presentations, evaluate these conclusions for clarity and precision, and (if needed) reconstruct / restate the conclusion in clear and precise terms; 
c.       identify stated premises or reasons in morally argumentative presentations, evaluate these conclusions for clarity and precision, and (if needed) reconstruct / restate these premises in clear and precise terms; 
d.      identify (if needed) unstated premises in argumentative presentations that are logically essential to the structure of an argument and state them as part of the argument in clear and precise terms;
e.       identify and distinguish factual/empirical/scientific and moral/philosophical premises in moral arguments;
f.       evaluate moral arguments as (1) logically valid or invalid (or otherwise logically cogent) and (2) sound orunsound (or otherwise strong);
g.       identify and explain reasons given to think an argument is sound, reasons to think it is unsound (often using counterexamples to general moral premises), and responses to these reasons.

Students will be able to accurately explain historically influential moral theories and common arguments against them, in light of their implications, explanatory power and theoretical virtues and vices.

Students will be able to accurately explain (in essays and oral presentations) the most common arguments given on a number of controversial moral issues, from a variety of perspectives, and criticisms of these arguments.

Monday
Tuesday
1.       June 5

OVERVIEW OF COURSE; INTRODUCTIONS; INTRODUCTION TO LOGIC


Wednesday
2.       June 6

INTRODUCTION TO LOGIC CONTINUED

READ:    “Some Basic Points about Arguments," James Rachels (from The Right Thing to Do)

ONLINE LINK BELOW
Thursday
3.       June 7

INTRODUCTION TO MORAL THEORIES

READ: James Rachels, "A Short Introduction to Moral Philosophy" (from The Right Thing to Do): (focus on the 2nd half: utilitarianism, Kantianism and social contract theory).  

ONLINE LINK BELOW
Friday
4.       June 8

Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH 1:
Available here if you don’t have the book yet (but it is on reserve in the library:

Main topics: moral thinking; disabled newborns and children.

End of drop/add period
5.       June 11
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  1

Main topics: moral thinking; disabled newborns and children.

Withdrawal period begins


6.       June 12
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  2

Main topics: cultural relativism; female genital mutilation; polyamory.
7.       June 13
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  2

Main topics: cultural relativism; female genital mutilation; polyamory.
8.       June 14
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  3

Topics: homosexuality

Additional writing: Arguments lists: state at least 10 reasons people sometimes give to think that homosexuality is wrong.
9.       June 15
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  3

Topics: homosexuality
10.    June 18
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  4

Topics: morality and religion; abortion

Additional writing: Arguments lists: state at least 10 reasons people sometimes give to think that abortion is wrong and at least 5 reasons to think it is morally permissible.
11.    June 19
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  4

Topics: morality and religion; abortion
12.    June 20
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  5

Topics: ethical egoism; poverty

Midterm week
Arguments lists: state at least 5 reasons people give to think that we are obligated to help absolutely poor people and at least 5 reasons to think it is morally permissible to not help absolutely poor people .
13.    June 21
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  5

Topics: ethical egoism; poverty

Midterm week
14.    June 22
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  6

Topic: social contract theory; civil disobedience.
Midterm week

READINGS:



15.    June 25
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  7 & 8

Topics: utilitarianism; euthanasia, drug use, treatment of animals

Additional writing: Arguments lists: state at least 10 reasons people sometimes give to think that eating meat is morally permissible, i.e., not wrong and at least 5 reasons to think that it is morally permissible.
16.    June 26
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  7 & 8

Topics: utilitarianism; euthanasia, drug use, treatment of animals

“Reasonable Humans and Animals,” John Simmons: LINK BELOW
17.    June 27
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  7 & 8

Topics: utilitarianism; euthanasia, drug use, treatment of animals
18.    June 28
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  9 & 10

Topic s: Kant’s ethics; war, capital punishment

Additional writing: Arguments lists: state at least 5 reasons people sometimes give to think that capital punishment is wrong and at least 5 reasons to think that it is or can be morally permissible.
19.    June 29
Read: RACHELS, ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY CH  9 & 10

Topic s: Kant’s ethics; war, capital punishment

Last day to withdraw
20.    July 2

OPEN
21.    July 3

OPEN
July 4 – no class
Reading day 1 – no class
Reading day 2 – no class
July 9 – Final Exam week

Final exam day and time TBA
July 10 - Final Exam week

Final exam day and time TBA
July 11 – final exam week

Final exam day and time TBA
July 12 – final exam week

Final exam day and time TBA
July 13 – final exam week

Final exam day and time TBA; semester ends

July 17: grades due by noon




READINGS
10 CHAPTERS OF JAMES AND STUART RACHELS’ THE ELEMENTS OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY
·         APPROX 14 PAGES PER CHAPTER; EASY AND INTERESTING READING! LOTS OF INTERESTING EXAMPLES!
·         Read them before class, so have them read for the day on the schedule above; bring the book and reading(s) to class.
·         A copy of the book is available on reserve in the library: photocopy chapters if you need to.  
A few online readings:
·         Day 2: “Some Basic Points about Arguments," James Rachels (from The Right Thing to Do): http://aphilosopher.googlepages.com/rachels-on-arguments.pdf
·         Day 3: "A Short Introduction to Moral Philosophy" James Rachels (from The Right Thing to Do): http://aphilosopher.googlepages.com/rachels-intro-to-ethics.pdf (focus on the 2nd half: utilitarianism, Kantianism and social contract theory).  
·         John Simmons, “Reasonable Humans and Animals,” http://sites.google.com/site/nobisphilosophy/veg.pdf
·         Other items handed out in class: keep them with you and bring to class.

ASSIGNMENTS AND GRADING:
·         DETAILED WRITTEN SUMMARIES OF EACH CHAPTER(S); DUE BEFORE CLASS, TO ENSURE YOU HAVE DONE THE READINGS. 5 points per chapter (50 points total); Please send work to this email and/or turn in in class in hardcopy: nobishomework@gmail.com
·         5 additional list-building assignments where students make lists of reasons given for and against various moral conclusions: these lists can be developed from your own observations and reflections, discussions with other people and/or internet searching; students will also be asked to formulate these arguments as logically valid arguments (explanation forthcoming!). 5 points per list (25 points total). These are due on the day they are noted on the calendar. Please send work to this email and/or turn in in class in hardcopy: nobishomework@gmail.com
·         Two quizzes, midterm and final, in class: 25 points each, (50 points total). Study guides, practice quizes and study sessions will be provided.
·         There may be some extra credit assignments.
·         Attendance will be taken; unexcused absences and tardies beyond 3 will result in 2 points off the final grade. 

·         Any late work will be penalized.
·         Any plagiarized work will be given a zero grade and no chance for makeup or plagiarism will result in failing the course and a report to the dean. Do not use anyone else’s work in this course and do not try to find anything from the internet to submit as an assignment: do your own work without any input from outside sources (except when you are asked to do so).
·         Please do not text or use computers in class for non-class purposes; please put away phones and turn off your internet connection, unless asked to use the internet.